Quick answer
The best eyelash curler for most people is the Tweezerman Classic. It lifts lashes well, holds the curl and comes with refill pads. The Shiseido curler is worth the small extra cost if you want every lash caught. On a tight budget, the e.l.f. Pro does the basic job well.
We pick products from Amazon reviews and research, and no brand pays to be here. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. How we choose
Our picks at a glance
Tap the heart to save onePeople who want a curl that stays up, including thin lashes
People who want every lash lifted, with a curl that lasts all day
People who want a spare pad and an easy grip at a low price
Keeping one curler at home and one in your bag
People who curl every day and go through pads quickly
Straight lashes that drop a manual curl by lunchtime
Key takeaways
- The curve of the curler matters most. It needs to match the shape of your eyelid.
- A fresh pad gives a softer, more even curl. Replace it when it gets a groove.
- Curl before mascara, never after, so lashes do not stick and break.
- Heated curlers help straight lashes hold a curl, but they tend to wear out sooner.
On this page
How our picks compare
| Product | Best for | Buyers love | Watch out for | Price | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tweezerman Classic Eyelash Curler Best overall |
People who want a curl that stays up, including thin lashes | A curl that stays up through the day | The curve does not suit every eye shape | $$Mid-range price | Check price |
| Shiseido Eyelash Curler Best for catching every lash |
People who want every lash lifted, with a curl that lasts all day | Catches the whole lash line | Costs more than a drugstore curler | $$Mid-range price | Check price |
| e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler Best budget |
People who want a spare pad and an easy grip at a low price | Inexpensive | Many buyers say the arm pinches a cheek, or the curl does not hold | $Budget price | Check price |
| wet n wild High On Lash Eyelash Curler, 2-Pack Best value pack |
Keeping one curler at home and one in your bag | $Budget price | Check price | ||
| Kaasage Eyelash Curler with 5 Refill Pads Best for spare pads |
People who curl every day and go through pads quickly | $Budget price | Check price | ||
| docolor Heated Eyelash Curler Best heated curler |
Straight lashes that drop a manual curl by lunchtime | $Budget price | Check price |
Our picks, reviewed
Tweezerman Classic Eyelash Curler
Best for: People who want a curl that stays up, including thin lashes
Our verdict
It gives a lasting curl, even on thin lashes, and the refill pads keep it working the same way for a long time.
What recent buyers say
Buyers say it is the best curler they have used. Thin lashes still curl, the rubber does not rip them out, and the lift lasts through the day. The extra pads are a reason people mention for buying it, and several say the curl is strong enough that they skip mascara some days.
What buyers like
- A curl that stays up through the day
- Gentle on thin lashes
- Three spare pads in the box
- Smooth squeeze, no crimp
Common complaints
- The curve does not suit every eye shape
Skip it if the clamp pinches the inner corner of your eye. A shallower curve may sit better.
Shiseido Eyelash Curler
Best for: People who want every lash lifted, with a curl that lasts all day
Our verdict
The broad, shallow curve reaches the whole lash line, and the squeeze is light. It costs a little more and is worth it if cheaper curlers miss your outer lashes.
What recent buyers say
Buyers say it curls every lash and the lift holds all day. They like how gentle it feels next to a drugstore curler, and that a spare pad comes with it. People who have used it for years say the curl is the reason they keep buying it.
What buyers like
- Catches the whole lash line
- Curl lasts all day, even on short lashes
- Light, gentle squeeze
- Spare pad included
Common complaints
- Costs more than a drugstore curler
Skip it if you want the cheapest curler that still includes spare pads.
e.l.f. Pro Eyelash Curler
Best for: People who want a spare pad and an easy grip at a low price
Our verdict
A low price, an easy grip and a spare pad in the box. It is the one to buy if you are not sure you will curl often.
What recent buyers say
Happy buyers mention three things: the price, the spare pad, and a curl that does not leave a crease. They like the soft grip, and some say the pad has no slit to catch lashes.
What buyers like
- Inexpensive
- Spare pad in the box
- Grip that is easy to hold
- A clean curl for the people it suits
Common complaints
- Many buyers say the arm pinches a cheek, or the curl does not hold
Skip it if you have been pinched by curlers before and want the shallow curve of the Shiseido.
wet n wild High On Lash Eyelash Curler, 2-Pack
Best for: Keeping one curler at home and one in your bag
Our verdict
Two curlers for about the price of one. Keep one by the mirror and one in your makeup bag.
Skip it if you want the most even curl, since the higher-rated curlers do a little better.
Kaasage Eyelash Curler with 5 Refill Pads
Best for: People who curl every day and go through pads quickly
Our verdict
Five refill pads come in the box. That covers months of daily curling before you need to restock.
Skip it if you curl only now and then and do not need extra pads.
docolor Heated Eyelash Curler
Best for: Straight lashes that drop a manual curl by lunchtime
Our verdict
For straight lashes that drop a regular curl by lunch. The gentle heat helps the curl set and hold.
Skip it if you want a tool that lasts for years, since heated curlers tend to have a short life.
How to choose an eyelash curler
The biggest difference between curlers is the shape of the curve. If it does not match your eyelid, it will miss the outer lashes or pinch the skin.
| Your eyes | What to look for | Our pick |
|---|---|---|
| Round or wide open | A broad, shallow curve | Shiseido |
| Most eye shapes | A classic mid curve | Tweezerman Classic |
| Hooded or deep-set | A curler that fits under the lid, or a heated comb | docolor heated |
| Straight lashes that will not hold a curl | Gentle heat | docolor heated |
| You lose curlers often | A multi-pack | wet n wild 2-pack |
After the curve, check the pad. A soft, replaceable pad gives a rounder curl and is kinder to your lashes. Curlers that come with spare pads, like the Tweezerman and Kaasage, save you a trip to the store.
How we chose
We started with the curlers that have both high ratings and large numbers of ratings on Amazon. A curler with a slightly lower rating from tens of thousands of people can be a safer bet than a perfect score from a few dozen.
We left off curlers whose ratings trailed the rest, even well-known names. For heated curlers, we only included models with a real base of reviews. Several newer heated curlers have near-perfect scores from very few buyers, so we left them out for now.
How to curl your lashes without pinching
- Start with clean, dry lashes and no mascara.
- Look down into a mirror. This lifts your lid out of the way.
- Open the curler wide and place it at the base of your lashes.
- Check that no skin is inside the curler, then squeeze gently for a few seconds.
- Move the curler halfway up your lashes and squeeze again for a softer, rounded curl.
- Add mascara right away to help the curl hold.
Our guide on how to curl your eyelashes has more detail, including the best method for each eye shape.
When it is worth spending more
Spending more makes sense when cheap curlers do not fit your eye. The Shiseido curler costs a little more than drugstore curlers, and buyers say its curve reaches more of the lash line. That is the main thing extra money buys.
A heated curler is worth it only if your lashes drop a curl within a few hours. If a regular curler already works for you, a heated one will not change much. Our list of heated eyelash curlers compares the options.
Common mistakes and safety
- Curling after mascara. Wet or dry mascara makes lashes stick to the pad. That can pull them out.
- Using a worn pad. A grooved pad pinches and gives a sharp crease instead of a curve.
- Using a damaged curler. One case report describes a serious eye injury from an eyelash curler that broke during use 1. Throw out a curler with a bent frame or loose parts.
- Sharing. The FDA advises against sharing eye cosmetics, and it says any tool used near the eye should be clean 2. Wipe the pad and frame often.
- Curling in the car. The FDA warns that a bump while you apply eye makeup in a moving vehicle can scratch your eye 2.
If you wear false lashes, curl your natural lashes first. Then see our picks for lash cluster kits and lash applicators. For everything else for your makeup bag, start at our makeup tools hub.
More lash and brow tools lists
Questions people ask
What is the best eyelash curler?
The best eyelash curler for most people is the Tweezerman Classic. It holds a curl well and comes with refill pads. The Shiseido curler is a good step up if cheaper curlers miss some of your lashes.
What should I look for in an eyelash curler?
In an eyelash curler, look first for a curve that matches your eyelid. Then look for a soft, replaceable pad and a squeeze that feels gentle. Spare pads in the box are a bonus.
Are expensive eyelash curlers worth it?
Expensive eyelash curlers are worth it only if a cheap one does not fit your eye shape. The fit of the curve matters more than the price. Most good curlers, including our top pick, are still inexpensive.
How long do eyelash curlers last?
An eyelash curler can last for years if you replace the pad. Change the pad when it gets a deep groove or cracks. Replace the whole curler if the frame bends or the parts get loose.
What is the best lash curler for hooded eyes?
The best lash curler for hooded eyes is one that fits under the lid without pinching it. A curler with a flatter, shallower curve often fits better. A heated comb-style curler is another option, because you brush it through your lashes instead of clamping.
How do I use an eyelash curler that does not pinch?
To use an eyelash curler without pinching, look down into a mirror and open the curler wide before you bring it to your eye. Place it at the base of your lashes, check that no skin is inside, then squeeze gently. A worn pad can also cause pinching, so replace it.
Should I curl my lashes before or after mascara?
You should curl your lashes before mascara. Curling after mascara can make lashes stick to the pad and pull or break. If you want more hold, add mascara right after curling.
How often should I replace the eyelash curler pad?
You should replace the eyelash curler pad when it has a deep groove or starts to crack. For many people that is every few months with daily use. A fresh pad gives a softer, rounder curl.
Are heated eyelash curlers better?
Heated eyelash curlers are better for very straight lashes that will not hold a curl. They are not better for everyone. Many people get a great curl from a regular curler, and heated curlers tend to wear out sooner.
Sources
- 1 Ramasamy B, Armstrong S Penetrating eye injury caused by eyelash curlers: a cause for concern? . Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol , 2010 ; 248(3):301-3 . Study
- 2 Eye cosmetic safety . US Food and Drug Administration . Government