Christmas gift guides are hereFind a gift

How we choose products

Last updated

Every pick on this site comes from the same method. We do not take payment for placement, and brands cannot buy a spot on a list. Here is exactly how a product earns its place.

1. We start with proven sellers

First, we look at the overall star rating and how many people left one. Both matter. A tool rated 4.6 by 20,000 buyers tells us far more than one rated 4.9 by 40, because a small number of ratings can swing on a few happy customers.

So we build a shortlist of tools with strong ratings from a large number of buyers. Then the real reading starts.

2. We read the newest reviews first

Products change. A brand can switch factories, change a motor, or swap a material, and the reviews from three years ago will not tell you. That is why we give the most weight to recent reviews.

If a tool’s newest reviews start mentioning overheating, peeling plates or a battery that dies early, it drops down the list or comes off it.

3. We pay close attention to 4-star reviews

Five-star reviews are often short and happy. One-star reviews are often about shipping or a single faulty unit. Four-star reviews are where the useful detail lives.

Four-star reviewers like the product enough to recommend it, and they still tell you what bugs them. That is how we learn that a dryer is great but heavy, or that a lamp cures fast but runs hot. We use those details to write the “Skip it if” line on each card.

4. We check the science

Some tools make claims, like LED masks, microcurrent devices, IPL and derma rollers. For those, we read the studies and link to them, so you can see what the research found and how strong it is. If the evidence is thin, we say so.

5. We match each tool to a person

A tool is only “best” for someone. That is why every pick has a “Best for” line, and why our lists are split by hair type, skin type and need. The best hair dryer for fine hair is rarely the best one for thick curls.

What you will and will not see on our cards

You will seeYou will not see
What recent buyers say, in our own wordsCopied customer reviews
What buyers like and their common complaintsMade-up testing claims
A price tier from $ to $$$Exact prices, which change daily on Amazon
The month we last checked the reviewsStar ratings copied from Amazon

We do not show exact prices or Amazon star ratings, because both change often and Amazon has rules about how they can be displayed. Click “Check price on Amazon” to see the live price and rating.

How we keep lists fresh

We recheck listings regularly and update the “Reviews checked” date on each card when we do. If a product is discontinued or its recent reviews slip, we replace it.

How we make money

When you buy through a link on this site, we may earn a commission from Amazon at no extra cost to you. That pays for the research. It never decides what we recommend. You can read our full affiliate disclosure.

A note on health

Our guides are general information. They are not medical advice. If you have a skin condition, an allergy, or you are pregnant, check with a doctor or dermatologist before trying a new device.

Search Gathering Perfection